Wednesday, April 1, 2009

Re-Framing the Public School Debate

“Frames are the mental structures that allow human beings to understand reality—sometimes to create what we take to be reality.” Lakoff

Do you believe that the American business model applied to schools will produce better teachers and more qualified students? Then your thought process about public schools is probably mired in the myths fostered by the 1980’s report, A Nation at Risk, which claimed that, the failure of our public schools would eventually lead to our economic decline and inability to compete in the world market. Those findings were driven by a right wing ideology from the likes of CEO’s and business leaders who posed the idea that we can only keep our competitive position in the world by improving our schools.

Time and our current economic situation have proven that those ideas were pitched to open the door for conservatives to take control of the public school debate. And, they succeeded, as that idea took hold, educators and teacher unions at all levels, ceded their leadership in the field to business moguls who despite public acts of helping schools with funding for charter schools and laptops, secretly professed that they want to ultimately privatize the schools to make a lot of money.

Now, we seem to be stuck in the rhetorical frame that public schools are failing despite the facts that indicate a different reality. That frame is the elephant in the room and no one has been able to change our concept to another reality. Schools are living up to the standards we set for them. Today, according to the 2004 Census, more kids graduate high school than ever before. (We need to improve those numbers for minorities, especially Hispanics, but over all those figures are rising.) Around 28 percent of our national population gets a 4-year college degree and in New York State it’s sits at 30 percent. And, based upon 2006 statistics from G-8 countries, we are scoring very well in most categories of reading and math. (Don't get me wrong, there is still plenty of room for improvement.)

Yet, because the debate is framed around the idea that our schools are failing, those who call for privatizing schools have gained a foothold with the general public in the public education debate. Even though the general public thinks schools are failing, parents consistently think that the schools their children attend are good. The incongruity of that thinking, however, doesn’t seem to make an impression because the picture of failing public schools is so entrenched in the national mind-set.

We also hear, but not so loudly at this moment in our economic history, that the business model should be applied to schools. The belief is that children are revenue sources and schools should be able to generate a profit. How do you increase profit? Add additional revenue sources, reduce expenditures, cut salaries, break the negotiating strength of unions and, of course, eliminate all regulations and standards of accountability. In addition, these business leaders throw in the concept of merit pay as an incentive to teachers so they will teach to the bottom line--standardized tests. It works for businesses, doesn’t it? Well....

To make this all sound palatable to the general public, conservatives have convinced the public that public education has failed the nation and they design schemes that ultimately and deliberately underfund the school system. (Unfunded mandates in NCLB, vouchers, charter schools, home schooling) With unrealistic and ill conceived demands and continuously diverted resources, schools would become nothing but holding pens festering with failure. That’s because conservative school reform movements are akin to the urban renewal efforts that were the results of landlord-arsonists in the Bronx or the fire-bomb deliberately dropped by police in a Philadelphia residential neighborhood to root out a small band of dissidents. Those efforts had the effect of displacing and silencing a noisy, but ultimately, powerless minority for the profit of the few.

Public schools are doing the job they were meant to do. They are acculturating a diverse population that can unite us as one democratic nation with faith in the possibilities of every individual. This last election gave us a glimpse at what that future would look like. Better schools aren't about a better economy. Improving schools is about becoming a better country. That’s how we should frame future discussions about public education.

13 comments:

Mark Kreider said...

Hi Crowman,
Very nice blog! I'm forwarding your link to my niece who is a Bronx high school teacher. I know she'll find food for thought here. Just got back from a week in the Keys (Big Pine) and not one single day was suitable for safe fly fishing with lightning potential. Water was too cold for fish to be hanging around on the flats anyway, 69 degrees. Bones and tarpon like high 80s and 90s. Soon we'll be able to fish here... can't wait.

dissertation layout example said...

interesting! its great, I love this article very much including me and my friends very much because i got my desired information in your posting. keep it up and continue your work
dissertation layout | dissertation

Uk Dissertation Writing Services said...

The information you provided is quite simple and clear for knowledge seeker. Thanks for your research anyways.

Dissertation help said...

Extremely useful and informative article. I wish i can do all of that in a short period of time. But for sure doing those will produce results. I will try to spread your words through my blog and link it back to you. Thanks a lot for those tips.

Viko said...

I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains wonderful and helpful posts. I have read most of them and got a lot from them. Thesis writing.To me, you are doing the great work.My ip address.Carry on this. work at home In the end, I would like to thank you for making such a nice website.

Dissertation Help said...

Nicely explained. It's indeed an art to stop new visitors with your attractive writing style. Truly impressive and nice information. Thanks for sharing.Dissertation Help|Custom Dissertation

Dissertation Writing Help said...

hmm...your post is good. i really like it. . .nice job keep sharing ;)
UK Dissertation Help

Cyned said...

Hello,
I can see from your posts that you are interested in issues regarding education in our country. Please be aware that a national movement has been coalescing and has now come together.

Educators and parent groups all over the country are supporting our national grassroots movement to take back control of our schools. We are sponsoring a march in Washington, D.C. on July 30, and we have issued a national call to action. One of our many endorsements has come from Diane Ravitch. She and other important educators will be presenting in Washington at events surrounding the March.

How can you help? Please visit our website www.saveourschoolsmarch.org and please help us get out the word! This is such a politically crucial time for the PUBLIC schools! They are under attack from legislators, the media, and even our National and State Government . We’d love to have you blog about us and we’d love to have your blog link to our website. Together, we will speak with ONE VOICE. We WILL be heard.

Cindi Pastore
www.saveourschoolsmarch.org

Amanda said...

I have been reading so many blogs since I am using internet but till now, this one is the one stop solution to all the problems I have been facing. Thank you.

writing a dissertation

pamella said...

This is my Good luck that I found your post which is according to my search and topic, I think you are a great blogger, thanks for helping me outta my problem..
Dissertation Methodology Help

Osse said...

i really like your post .. i would like to bookmark your site for my future needs :)
dissertations

dissertation said...

That's look great that people would love to share their educational matters and experience on internet, this would be good for readers who must face again this issues in their projects.
Dissertation Help

custom dissertation said...

Your post is very informative. You have written it very well. I will keep on coming here to check new updates. Thanks for sharing this article.